Open
Description
The bug
It seems that the album comments button on the mobile app is a bit broken:
- First it leads to all comments in this album
- When we open any asset (in this album or not), it starts leading to the comments of the last opened asset
- Using this, we can leave a comment on any asset we previously opened
Consider this album setup:
You can leave a comment to the photo outside the album when using the mobile app
When clicking on this broken photo we get this error:
But in case the commented user uses partner sharing with us, the photo is viewable (as in the first image), and we can even comment on it
Also want to note, but I'm not sure if it is work as expected:
- Asset-related comments remain if we remove the asset from the album (comments count and their contets remains)
- Asset-related comments remain if we trash the asset (comments count decreases, but they are still viewable, for example, it shows 4 comments count but we can see 6 comments)
- And only if we delete the asset completely, then the comments disappear
It also would be cool to have TextCapitalization.sentences on the keyboard in the comments section
The OS that Immich Server is running on
Ubuntu 20.04.6 LTS
Version of Immich Server
v1.126.1
Version of Immich Mobile App
1.126.1 build.184
Platform with the issue
- Server
- Web
- Mobile
Your docker-compose.yml content
n/a
Your .env content
n/a
Reproduction steps
- Start the app (force close it first)
- Create an album, add users to it
- Navigate to your own library and tap to view any backed up asset
- Swipe down the asset and navigate back to our album
- Tap the comments button
- Write a comment
- Now the album has a comment linked to the last viewed photo even if it is not inside the album
Relevant log output
Additional information
Using Samsung Galaxy S22 Ultra, Android 14, but not sure if it is platform dependant
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels