Skip to content

Change "rejected" to "changes requested" in 3rd party PR review notification #34481

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom
Merged
merged 1 commit into from
May 16, 2025
Merged

Change "rejected" to "changes requested" in 3rd party PR review notification #34481

merged 1 commit into from
May 16, 2025

Conversation

s-weigand
Copy link
Contributor

@s-weigand s-weigand commented May 15, 2025 •
edited
Loading

This PR changes 3rd party notifications wording on a PR review that requests changes and can be considered a follow up for #5858 to also fix #5857 in 3rd party notifications.

The difference in the actual notification would be the following:

- Pull request review rejected
+ Pull request review changes requested

While this is a simple string change at first look, it has a deeper UX meaning.

Motivation

We could observe that some developers are hesitant to press the "Request changes" button since their peers first see that their changes were rejected, thus a more appropriate wording that also falls in line with the meaning and UI would be beneficial.

Meaning

Pressing the Request changes button in a PR review means that as a reviewer you are willing to merge the general change in a PR if changes requested review comments are implemented.
Rejecting a PR on the other hand would be equivalent with closing it since that change isn't welcome at all (e.g. out of scope feature).

Sync with UI

The UI button says request changes and the other options

image

Considered Problems

This might break some automation for users who rely on string matching.

@GiteaBot GiteaBot added the lgtm/need 2 This PR needs two approvals by maintainers to be considered for merging. label May 15, 2025
@github-actions github-actions bot added the modifies/go Pull requests that update Go code label May 15, 2025
@GiteaBot GiteaBot added lgtm/need 1 This PR needs approval from one additional maintainer to be merged. and removed lgtm/need 2 This PR needs two approvals by maintainers to be considered for merging. labels May 15, 2025
@lunny lunny added this to the 1.25.0 milestone May 15, 2025
@GiteaBot GiteaBot added lgtm/done This PR has enough approvals to get merged. There are no important open reservations anymore. and removed lgtm/need 1 This PR needs approval from one additional maintainer to be merged. labels May 16, 2025
@techknowlogick techknowlogick changed the title 👌 Change "rejected" to "changes requested" in 3rd party PR review notification Change "rejected" to "changes requested" in 3rd party PR review notification May 16, 2025
@techknowlogick techknowlogick merged commit 7b518bc into go-gitea:main May 16, 2025
26 checks passed
@s-weigand s-weigand deleted the reword-notification branch May 16, 2025 07:36
zjjhot added a commit to zjjhot/gitea that referenced this pull request May 19, 2025
@zjjhot
Merge remote-tracking branch 'giteaofficial/main'
94d765d 
* giteaofficial/main:
  [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
  Fix edithook api can not update package, status and workflow_job events (go-gitea#34495)
  Fix url validation in webhook add/edit API (go-gitea#34492)
  Add R-HNF to the TRANSLATORS file (go-gitea#34494)
  Add missing setting load in dump-repo command (go-gitea#34479)
  nix flake update (go-gitea#34476)
  Fix get / delete runner to use consistent http 404 and 500 status (go-gitea#34480)
  Change "rejected" to "changes requested" in 3rd party PR review notification (go-gitea#34481)
  Add migrations tests (go-gitea#34456)
  Fix project board view (go-gitea#34470)
saschazepter pushed a commit to saschazepter/forgejo that referenced this pull request Jun 27, 2025
@jerger @s-weigand @lunny
[gitea] week 2025-19 cherry pick (gitea/main -> forgejo) (#7909)
aee161f 
## Checklist

- [x] go to the last cherry-pick PR (forgejo/forgejo#7804) to figure out how far it went: [gitea@a2024953c5](go-gitea/gitea@a202495)
- [x] cherry-pick and open PR (forgejo/forgejo#7909)
- [ ] have the PR pass the CI
- end-to-end (specially important if there are actions related changes)
  - [ ] add `run-end-to-end` label
  - [ ] check the result
- [ ] write release notes
- [ ] assign reviewers
- [ ] 48h later, last call
- merge 1 hour after the last call

## Legend

- ❓ - No decision about the commit has been made.
- 🍒 - The commit has been cherry picked.
- ⏩ - The commit has been skipped.
- 💡 - The commit has been skipped, but should be ported to Forgejo.
- ✍️ - The commit has been skipped, and a port to Forgejo already exists.

## Commits

- 🍒 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@e92c4f1) -> [`forgejo`](https://codeberg.org/forgejo/forgejo/commit/56fa2caef32c4b0e5017f4b09188ad1dfc8d3603) Add missing setting load in dump-repo command ([gitea#34479](go-gitea/gitea#34479))
- 🍒 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@7b518bc) -> [`forgejo`](https://codeberg.org/forgejo/forgejo/commit/6e5299606a1bd42cb45ed472a84ba797cf2fa790) Change "rejected" to "changes requested" in 3rd party PR review notification ([gitea#34481](go-gitea/gitea#34481))

## TODO

- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@9723810) Fix url validation in webhook add/edit API ([gitea#34492](go-gitea/gitea#34492))
  Relevant input validation but test needs more backport.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@59df03b) Fix get / delete runner to use consistent http 404 and 500 status ([gitea#34480](go-gitea/gitea#34480))
  It may be relevant to Forgejo as well
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@1e2f351) Add endpoint deleting workflow run ([gitea#34337](go-gitea/gitea#34337))
  Actions, it would be worth having in Forgejo as well.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@5cb4cbf) Fix repo broken check ([gitea#34444](go-gitea/gitea#34444))
  Check wether this is relevant to us, port if yes.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@355e9a9) Add a webhook push test for dev branch ([gitea#34421](go-gitea/gitea#34421))
  Enhances webhook integration tests.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@34281bc) Fix bug webhook milestone is not right. ([gitea#34419](go-gitea/gitea#34419))
  Testcode diverged, port required.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@780e92e) Only git operations should update `last changed` of a repository ([gitea#34388](go-gitea/gitea#34388))
  Port required, would benefit from additional tests.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@b07e039) When updating comment, if the content is the same, just return and not update the databse ([gitea#34422](go-gitea/gitea#34422))
  Codebase diverged, port required.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@71a1187) Fix incorrect divergence cache after switching default branch ([gitea#34370](go-gitea/gitea#34370))
  Depends on previous gitea changes, port needed.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@4c611bf) Add a button editing action secret ([gitea#34348](go-gitea/gitea#34348))
  This is an interesting feature and it has tests as well. Feature request covering this: https://codeberg.org/forgejo/forgejo/issues/7882
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@2fbc8f9) Fix LFS file not stored in LFS when uploaded/edited via API or web UI ([gitea#34367](go-gitea/gitea#34367))
  Our code diverged - pls. check relevance & maybe port.
------
- 💡 [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@020e774) feat: add label 'state' to metric 'gitea_users' ([gitea#34326](go-gitea/gitea#34326))
  Adjust our existing tests while porting this.
------

## Skipped

- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@ec10c6b) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@d89eed9) Fix edithook api can not update package, status and workflow_job events ([gitea#34495](go-gitea/gitea#34495))

  - gitea actions specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@b6c0667)  Add R-HNF to the TRANSLATORS file ([gitea#34494](go-gitea/gitea#34494))

  - gitea translators update specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@6fbf0e6) nix flake update ([gitea#34476](go-gitea/gitea#34476))

  - gitea dependency update specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@c24f4b3) Add migrations tests ([gitea#34456](go-gitea/gitea#34456))
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@bf338bb) Fix project board view ([gitea#34470](go-gitea/gitea#34470))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@319d03f) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@dd500ce) Fix Workflow run Not Found page ([gitea#34459](go-gitea/gitea#34459))

  - gitea actions specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@b6bf128) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@a0595ad) Fix remove org user failure on mssql ([gitea#34449](go-gitea/gitea#34449))
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@b5fd3e7) Fix comment textarea scroll issue in Firefox ([gitea#34438](go-gitea/gitea#34438))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@4011e22) Fix releases sidebar navigation link ([gitea#34436](go-gitea/gitea#34436))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@0902d42) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@4a98ab0) Remove legacy template helper functions ([gitea#34426](go-gitea/gitea#34426))

  - gitea specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@9b8609e) Fix GetUsersByEmails ([gitea#34423](go-gitea/gitea#34423))

  - gitea specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@0f63a5e) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@ad27144) Fix a bug when uploading file via lfs ssh command ([gitea#34408](go-gitea/gitea#34408))
  :skiP: present with PR #7752
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@8b16ab7) Merge and tweak markup editor expander CSS ([gitea#34409](go-gitea/gitea#34409))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@2ecd73d) Bump `@github/relative-time-element` to v4.4.8 ([gitea#34413](go-gitea/gitea#34413))

  - gitea dependency update specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@179068f) Refactor commit message rendering and fix bugs ([gitea#34412](go-gitea/gitea#34412))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@44aadc3) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@f63822f) Fix autofocus behavior ([gitea#34397](go-gitea/gitea#34397))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@82071ee) [skip ci] Updated translations via Crowdin
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@bbfc21e) Fix "The sidebar of the repository file list does not have a fixed height #34298" ([gitea#34321](go-gitea/gitea#34321))

  - gitea ui specific specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@dd886d7) Update JS and PY dependencies ([gitea#34391](go-gitea/gitea#34391))

  - gitea dependency update specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@2a660b4) Upgrade go-github v61 -> v71 ([gitea#34385](go-gitea/gitea#34385))

  - gitea dependency update specific
------
- ⏩ [`gitea`](go-gitea/gitea@6bd8fe5) Bump `@github/relative-time-element` to v4.4.7 ([gitea#34384](go-gitea/gitea#34384))

  - gitea dependency update specific
------

<details>
<summary><h2>Stats</h2></summary>

<br>

Between [`gitea@a2024953c5`](go-gitea/gitea@a202495) and [`gitea@ec10c6ba5a`](go-gitea/gitea@ec10c6b), **41** commits have been reviewed. We picked **2**, skipped **27**, and decided to port **12**.

</details>

Co-authored-by: Sebastian Weigand <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Lunny Xiao <[email protected]>
Reviewed-on: https://codeberg.org/forgejo/forgejo/pulls/7909
Reviewed-by: Earl Warren <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Michael Jerger <[email protected]>
Co-committed-by: Michael Jerger <[email protected]>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Reviewers

@lunny lunny lunny approved these changes

@a1012112796 a1012112796 a1012112796 approved these changes

Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
lgtm/done This PR has enough approvals to get merged. There are no important open reservations anymore. modifies/go Pull requests that update Go code
Projects
None yet
Milestone
1.25.0
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Suggestion: rename "Reject" to "Request changes" (or similar)
5 participants
@s-weigand @lunny @a1012112796 @techknowlogick @GiteaBot