xSmbShare resource does not take into account properties other than Name, Path, Ensure when doing a Test-TargetResource

[TravisEz13]

The xSmbShare resource always tests false on our staging server, so the share is re-created every time and configuration drift is always reported.
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: LCM: [ Start Resource ] [[xSmbShare]XX]
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: LCM: [ Start Test ] [[xSmbShare]XX]
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: LCM: [ End Test ] [[xSmbShare]XX] in 0.0160 seconds.
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: LCM: [ Start Set ] [[xSmbShare]XX]
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: [[xSmbShare]XX] Share with name XX exists
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: [[xSmbShare]XX] Setting FullAccess for Everyone
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: LCM: [ End Set ] [[xSmbShare]XX] in 0.1870 seconds.
VERBOSE: [STGWEB1]: LCM: [ End Resource ] [[xSmbShare]XX]

There's nothing configuration-specific to investigate (excerpt from function Test-TargetResource):
if ($Ensure -eq "Present")
{
if ($share -eq $null)
{
$testResult = $false
}
elseif ($share -ne $null -and $PSBoundParameters.Count -gt 3)
# This means some other parameter in addition to Name, Path, Ensure could have been specified
# Which means we need to modify something
{
$testResult = $false
}
else
{
$testResult = $true
}
}
Rather than verifying the current configuration, this test assumes $false if parameters other than Name, Path, or Ensure are provided.

[SuperMarioo]

Test-TargetResource is not testing properly .
I did pull request with my fixes . I'm waiting for the resource to be reviewed .

[TravisEz13]

PR #3 was closed without merging for this issue.

[daBONDi]

Still not fixed nearly after 2 Years
Maybe Microsoft Abbond Powershell DSC 👎

[stinos]

Initially I also always got false test result, problem for me was that the usernames I used for the access parameters didn't have a domain prepended. Using (hostname) + 'user' instead of just 'user' did the trick. This should imo be documented though.

[daBONDi]

There are checks missing in the code, thats why, but the hassle microsoft do with this some kind of nda realy ruine the fun to fix it.

[johlju]

This issue has been resolved in the resource that is pending in PR dsccommunity/ComputerManagementDsc#211.

This resource is moving to ComputerManagementDsc, and the xSmbShare module will be deprecated once the resource has been moved.

Closing this issue at this time.