Refine prompt to avoid statements were it keeps the logic [3]

Author: karreiro

packages/vscode-extension/src/node/shopify-magic-prompts/base.ts

@@ -17,23 +17,31 @@ export function basePrompt(textEditor: TextEditor): string {
         <objective>Optimal Theme Development</objective>
       </prompt_metadata>
       <focus_areas>
-        <area>Enhancing readability, conciseness, and efficiency while maintaining the same functionality</area>
-        <area>Leveraging new features in Liquid, including filters, tags, and objects</area>
-        <area>Be pragmatic and don't suggest without a really good reason</area>
-        <area>Combine multiple operations into one to improve readability and performance -- for example, use the find filter instead of where and first, if find is a valid filter</area>
-        <area>You should not suggest changes to the code that impact only HTML -- they should be focused on Liquid and Theme features.</area>
-        <area>You should not talk about whitespaces and the style of the code; leave that to the linter!</area>
-        <area>**Do not suggest to keep** something that is already valid</area>
+        <area>**Enhance the conciseness and efficiency of Liquid code** while maintaining the same functionality</area>
+        <area>**Leverage the most appropriate Liquid** features (filters, tags, and objects); sometimes a filter can achieve the same result as a block of code</area>
+        <area>Avoid logic that matches the default behavior (especially for filters)</area>
+        <area>**Be pragmatic** and **do not suggest unless there's a strong reason**</area>
+        <area>Use filters for operations that perform the same function as a filter</area>
+        <area>Use unless for negative conditions</area>
       </focus_areas>
       <ensurance>
-        <point>The new code you propose contain full lines of valid code and keep the correct indentation, scope, and style format as the original code</point>
-        <point>Scopes are defined by the opened by "{%", "{{" with the matching closing element "%}" or "}}"</point>
-        <point>The range must include the closing element ("%}","}}") for every opening element ("{%","{{")</point>
+        <point>**Suggest only valid Liquid**</point>
+        <point>Suggested code must be different from the original code</point>
+        <point>**Do not suggest code styling changes**; it's best to leave that to the linter!</point>
+        <point>**Do not suggest refactorings** about combining variables</point>
+        <point>**Do not suggest keeping** something that is already good</point>
+        <point>**Do not suggest** changes that impact **only readability**</point>
+        <point>**Do not suggest** something that **changes the logic/functionality**</point>
+        <point>**Do not make up or create** new invalid Shopify Liquid features (filters, tags, objects, etc.)</point>
+        <point>**Do not suggest** changes that affect only **HTML**—focus on Liquid and Theme features instead</point>
+        <point>The new code you propose should contain full lines of valid code and maintain the correct indentation, scope, and style format as the original code</point>
+        <point>Scopes are defined by the opening of "{%" or "{{" with the matching closing element "%}" or "}}"</point>
+        <point>The range must include the closing element ("%}", "}}") for every opening element ("{%", "{{")</point>
         <point>Code suggestions cannot overlap in line numbers. If you have multiple suggestions for the same code chunk, merge them into a single suggestion</point>
         <point>Make full-scope suggestions that consider the entire context of the code you are modifying, keeping the logical scope of the code valid</point>
         <point>The resulting code must work and should not break existing HTML tags or Liquid syntax</point>
-        <point>The suggestions are specific, actionable, and align with the best practices in Liquid and Shopify theme development</point>
-        <point>Add a maximum of ${numberOfSuggestions} distinct suggestions to the array</point>
+        <point>The suggestions should be specific, actionable, and align with the best practices in Liquid and Shopify theme development</point>
+        <point>You must have zero up to a maximum of ${numberOfSuggestions} distinct suggestions to the array</point>
       </ensurance>
       <references>
         Use the <theme_architecture>, <liquid_rules>, and Shopify.dev context as a reference. Do not make up new information.

packages/vscode-extension/src/node/shopify-magic.ts

@@ -131,7 +131,10 @@ async function buildMessages(textEditor: TextEditor) {
     codeMetadataContext,
     liquidRulesContext,
     themeArchitectureContext,
-  ].map((message) => LanguageModelChatMessage.User(message));
+  ].map((message) => {
+    console.error(message);
+    return LanguageModelChatMessage.User(message);
+  });
 }
 
 function createHoverMessage(key: string, liquidSuggestion: LiquidSuggestion) {