Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
54 lines (32 loc) · 10.2 KB

render_frame_host_impl.md

File metadata and controls

54 lines (32 loc) · 10.2 KB

RenderFrameHostImpl Security

Component Focus: The RenderFrameHostImpl class in content/browser/renderer_host/render_frame_host_impl.cc, which is a central component in Chromium's rendering architecture.

Potential Logic Flaws:

  • Navigation and Redirection: Vulnerabilities in navigation and redirection handling could allow malicious websites to redirect users, bypass security checks, or perform phishing attacks. The interaction with the navigation controller (NavigationControllerImpl) and the handling of navigation requests (NavigationRequest) are critical. The DidNavigate and DidCommitNavigation functions, along with the handling of navigation parameters (CommonNavigationParams, CommitNavigationParams), are key areas for analysis.
  • Cross-Origin Resource Sharing (CORS): Flaws in CORS handling could allow unauthorized access to resources. RenderFrameHostImpl plays a key role in enforcing CORS policies. The CreateNetworkServiceDefaultFactory, CreateURLLoaderFactoryParamsForMainWorld, and UpdateSubresourceLoaderFactories functions are relevant for CORS.
  • Input Validation and Sanitization: Insufficient input validation and sanitization of data from the renderer process could lead to injection attacks. Many functions in render_frame_host_impl.cc receive data from the renderer, and thorough input validation is crucial. The DidCommitNavigation and DidCommitProvisionalLoad functions, which handle navigation commit parameters, are particularly important.
  • Frame Lifecycle Management: Improper handling of frame lifecycle events (creation, navigation, destruction) could lead to resource leaks or use-after-free vulnerabilities. The constructor, destructor, RenderFrameCreated, RenderFrameDeleted, Unload, and Detach functions are critical for frame lifecycle management.
  • Inter-Process Communication (IPC): The RenderFrameHostImpl communicates with the renderer process via IPC. Vulnerabilities in IPC handling could allow malicious websites to exploit the renderer or gain unauthorized access. The Send, OnMessageReceived, and various Bind... functions are relevant for IPC.
  • Race Conditions: The asynchronous nature of many operations within the RenderFrameHostImpl introduces potential race conditions. Navigation, resource loading, and event handling are all susceptible to race conditions. The interaction between the browser and renderer processes during navigation and rendering is a key area where race conditions could occur.

Further Analysis and Potential Issues:

The render_frame_host_impl.cc file ($36,013 VRP payout) implements the RenderFrameHostImpl class. Key areas and functions to investigate include:

  • Navigation and Redirection Handling (DidNavigate, DidCommitNavigation, DidCommitProvisionalLoad, DidCommitSameDocumentNavigation, BeginNavigation, OpenURL, CalculateLoadingURL, ValidateURLAndOrigin, CanCommitOriginAndUrl, CanSubframeCommitOriginAndUrl, UpdatePermissionsForNavigation, SendCommitNavigation, SendCommitFailedNavigation, ResetWaitingState): These functions handle various aspects of navigation, including URL validation, origin checks, security policy enforcement, and interaction with the navigation controller. Thorough analysis of these functions is crucial for preventing malicious redirects, bypasses of security checks, and other navigation-related vulnerabilities. The handling of navigation parameters, redirects, error conditions, and same-document navigations requires careful review. The asynchronous nature of navigation introduces potential race conditions that need to be addressed.

  • Frame Lifecycle Management (RenderFrameHostImpl constructor, destructor, RenderFrameCreated, RenderFrameDeleted, Unload, Detach, StartPendingDeletionOnSubtree, PendingDeletionCheckCompleted, OnUnloadACK, OnNavigationUnloadTimeout, OnSubframeDeletionUnloadTimeout, ResetChildren, EnsureDescendantsAreUnloading): These functions manage the lifecycle of a render frame, from creation to destruction. They should be reviewed for proper resource management, cleanup of state, and prevention of use-after-free vulnerabilities. The handling of unload handlers, detach events, and pending deletion states is critical for security and stability. The interaction with child frames and the frame tree structure should also be analyzed.

  • Input Validation and Sanitization (DidCommitProvisionalLoad, DidCommitSameDocumentNavigation, ValidateDidCommitParams, VerifyThatBrowserAndRendererCalculatedDidCommitParamsMatch, VerifyThatBrowserAndRendererCalculatedOriginsToCommitMatch, VerifyBeginNavigationCommonParams, VerifyNavigationInitiator, VerifyOpenURLParams, ValidateUnfencedTopNavigation, ValidateCSPAttribute): These functions and checks are responsible for validating and sanitizing various inputs received from the renderer process, such as URLs, origins, navigation parameters, and other data. Thorough input validation is essential to prevent injection attacks, such as XSS or command injection. The handling of different URL schemes, origins, and navigation types requires careful review.

  • Cross-Origin Resource Sharing (CORS) (CreateNetworkServiceDefaultFactory, CreateURLLoaderFactoryParamsForMainWorld, UpdateSubresourceLoaderFactories, CreateURLLoaderFactoriesForIsolatedWorlds, CreateCrossOriginPrefetchLoaderFactoryBundle, DetermineWhetherToForbidTrustTokenOperation, DetermineAfterCommitWhetherToForbidTrustTokenOperation): These functions manage the creation and updating of URL loader factories, which are responsible for handling subresource requests and enforcing CORS policies. They should be reviewed for proper handling of cross-origin requests, secure context enforcement, and prevention of CORS bypasses. The interaction with the network service and the handling of various security policies, such as COEP and COOP, are critical for security.

  • Inter-Process Communication (IPC) (Send, OnMessageReceived, BindBrowserInterfaceBrokerReceiver, BindAssociatedInterfaceProviderReceiver, and other Bind... functions): These functions handle communication between the browser and renderer processes. They should be reviewed for secure message passing, proper validation of IPC messages, and prevention of unauthorized access or data leakage. The use of Mojo interfaces and message pipes should be carefully analyzed.

  • Other Security-Relevant Functions (AccessibilityPerformAction, AccessibilityHitTest, DownloadURL, ReportInspectorIssue, StartDragging, ShowPopupMenu, ShowContextMenu, RunJavaScriptDialog, RunBeforeUnloadConfirm, CreateNewWindow, DidBlockNavigation, DidDisplayInsecureContent, DidContainInsecureFormAction, ExemptUrlFromNetworkRevocationForTesting, SendFencedFrameReportingBeacon, SendFencedFrameReportingBeaconToCustomURL, SetFencedFrameAutomaticBeaconReportEventData, DisableUntrustedNetworkInFencedFrame, CalculateUntrustedNetworkStatus, CreateFencedFrame, ForwardFencedFrameEventAndUserActivationToEmbedder): These functions handle various security-sensitive operations, such as accessibility actions, downloads, reporting of inspector issues, drag-and-drop, context menus, JavaScript dialogs, window creation, navigation blocking, handling of insecure content, fenced frame management, and other security-related tasks. They should be thoroughly reviewed for potential vulnerabilities, including input validation issues, data leakage, unauthorized access, and race conditions.

  • Race Conditions (General): The asynchronous nature of many operations within the RenderFrameHostImpl, such as navigation, resource loading, event handling, and IPC, introduces potential race conditions. These race conditions should be carefully analyzed and mitigated to prevent unexpected behavior or security vulnerabilities. The interaction between the browser and renderer processes during navigation and rendering is a key area where race conditions could occur.

Areas Requiring Further Investigation:

  • Analyze navigation and redirection handling for potential bypasses of security checks or malicious redirects. Pay close attention to the interaction with the navigation controller and the handling of navigation parameters.
  • Review CORS enforcement for potential weaknesses or bypasses. Focus on the handling of cross-origin resource requests and the interaction with the network stack.
  • Thoroughly analyze input validation and sanitization to prevent injection attacks. Review all functions receiving data from the renderer process.
  • Investigate frame lifecycle management for resource leaks, use-after-free vulnerabilities, and other security issues. Pay close attention to the handling of unload handlers, detach events, and pending deletion states.
  • Review IPC handling for secure communication and prevention of unauthorized access. Analyze the use of Mojo interfaces and message pipes.
  • Analyze the code for potential race conditions related to asynchronous operations, especially in navigation, resource loading, and event handling.
  • Investigate the interaction between the RenderFrameHostImpl and other browser components, such as the RenderProcessHost, the RenderViewHost, and the FrameTreeNode, for potential security implications.

Secure Contexts and RenderFrameHostImpl:

The RenderFrameHostImpl should be designed to operate securely within both secure (HTTPS) and insecure (HTTP) contexts. However, certain operations, such as handling sensitive data or interacting with potentially untrusted renderers, might require additional security measures in insecure contexts.

Privacy Implications:

Vulnerabilities in the RenderFrameHostImpl could potentially be exploited to leak sensitive browser data or user information. Therefore, privacy-preserving design and implementation are crucial. Pay close attention to the handling of user input, navigation history, and other potentially sensitive data.

Additional Notes:

The high VRP payout for render_frame_host_impl.cc highlights the importance of thorough security analysis for this central component in Chromium's rendering architecture. Files reviewed: content/browser/renderer_host/render_frame_host_impl.cc.